Windfalls, incentives and Monopoly
Markets and economies generally work because people have incentives to find welfare-enhancing trades. If you can keep the profit you make from a trade and spend it on something nice, you are more likely to make the trade. The same applies to working an extra few hours, or selling your car to someone who needs it more than you do. This is why incentives are important. And it is the basis of the major objection to high taxes and redistribution - it is meant to dilute incentives and discourage people from achieving maximum economic productivity. So what if the tax is a complete surprise? If a government creates a straight one-off windfall tax, it cannot affect economic behaviour before the windfall, because it is unforeseeable. It should not, in theory, affect economic behaviour after the windfall, because it is a one-off tax and therefore there is no reason to expect it will happen again. So why don't governments finance all their operations by a series one-off windfall taxes? Beca...